NOVEMBER 2008 (Volume 2, Number 11)                                                                                                                        Current circulation:  1,374
CRIME LAB REPORT
Media and public-policy analysis for the forensic science community

Copyright 2008 by Crime Lab Report.  All rights reserved.  This report contains opinions expressed by CRIME LAB REPORT, which is an independent organization.  These opinions may not necessarily represent those of our sponsors or other organizations affiliated with CRIME LAB REPORT and its editors.  While every effort is made to ensure accuracy and contextual honesty, all opinions should be corroborated with independent research before being construed as factual.  Crime Lab Report will quickly correct and/or retract any information demonstrated to be erroneous.  We welcome opposing viewpoints and will publish responses from our readers, which may be edited for economy and clarity.

www.crimelabreport.com

*     *     *     *     *

Business - the lifeblood of forensic science

November 19, 2008 by Crime Lab Report      Printer Friendly

Try practicing forensic science in a laboratory or collect physical evidence from a crime scene without equipment or supplies.  It doesn't take long to realize that forensic science as we know it could not exist without the support and involvement of some very patient and persistent companies able to survive in what is often a difficult and frustrating market. 

The profession of forensic science relies heavily on research and advancements in technology; therefore, entrepreneurial endeavors will always be a key measure of progress in the field whether they are fully appreciated as such or not. 

One of the most common practices for businesses seeking to establish a customer base in the forensic science community is to set up a booth at a major conference or symposium.  It is a proven method that affords vendors an opportunity to showcase their offerings directly to potential customers.  But because it can be a rather expensive proposition, it places pressure on sales representatives to make the most of the experience. 

"The forensic market is potentially quite small and, thus, not necessarily a high-profit arena," explains Max Houck, Director of West Virginia University's Forensic Science Initiative.  "Vendors think that because forensic science is a hot topic, there must be tons of money to be made. In reality, budgets can be very tight and funding quite slim." 

While these market conditions may seem ominous, it should inspire vendors to use creativity and hard work to make the most of their marketing dollars.  History shows that success is attainable.     

Tim Smith is the president of Porter Lee Corporation, which provides a widely used laboratory information management system affectionately called the BEAST (Bar-Coded Evidence And Statistics Tracking).  According to Smith, his experience of attending hundreds of forensic science meetings reveals one of the strategic threats facing companies that don’t stay active in the forensic science community. 

"Crime labs routinely communicate with one another thus many times a purchase decision is made outside of any communications with the vendor," observes Smith. 

Ultimately, science is about credibility and competence.  Businesses that are perceived as holding themselves to the same standards of accuracy and professionalism as their forensic clients will usually have more success over the long term. 

One forensic science leader who has witnessed the trials and tribulations of companies hoping to stand out among their competitors is Dean Gialamas, President of the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors (ASCLD).  As Gialamas points out, marketing to forensic scientists can be quite different from marketing to their bosses yet both are equally important. 

"At a meeting of crime lab directors, the best thing vendors can do is to understand the operational needs of crime labs," comments Gialamas.  "Some vendors end up just giving a sales pitch and lose the chance to build lasting relationships that are meaningful to them and our members.” 

One company that faced an unusually difficult battle in the early 1990's was Forensic Technology, Inc. (FTI) of Montreal, Canada.  FTI is the maker of the IBIS (NIBIN) system, which databases and digitizes images of bullets and cartridge cases for local, regional, and national searching. 

When FTI first came on the scene in the early 1990's, not only was their product unknown to the forensic science community, they faced heavy competition from Neumonic Systems, Inc., the company that contracted with the FBI to develop the Drugfire system.  As a result, FTI relied on persistence and relationship-building to grow a successful company that now employs over 200 people.    

"Make sure you approach the market as a partner and not just a seller," advises Mike McLean, one of the original members of the FTI team.  "Making the scientists a part of research programs and soliciting their feedback for product development will allow the end user to embrace change more quickly and accept what you have. If they feel part of the process they will embrace products more freely." 

In light of the unique challenges facing companies hoping to connect with crime labs, we hope that all forensic science professionals will remember to support and interact with the businesses that make forensic science possible.   

We also hope that sales representatives will be proactive in reaching out to practitioners and managers in the marketplace.  To support this effort, Crime Lab Report offers the following ten tips to help businesses that want to make a splash in the forensic science community: 

10.  When attending forensic meetings, be enthusiastic about the value of your products and services.  If it wasn't for you, there would be no such thing as a forensic science laboratory.  As Mike McLean noted, "be confident yet humble. Don’t act like you know it all and that you can solve all their problems.  You cannot solve everything but by asking questions and trying to understand you can build trust and respect for years to come."  

9.  Get out and chat with people.  Organizations often hold meals and breaks in the exhibit areas to draw in the meeting's attendees.  Take advantage of this courtesy and don't wait for future clients to come to you.   

8.  Create a booth that sparks curiosity.  Scientists love to explore without being distracted so be sure to cater to this natural instinct.  Also, be careful where you place your tables.  They can become obstacles that turn potential clients away from your booth. 

7.  Don't limit your conversations to sales pitches.  Talk to the scientists about their work, their goals, and the challenges they face each day.  You will be surprised what you learn and they will be more likely to approach you at future meetings. 

6.  Be everywhere.  Diversify your marketing strategy and use online venues and advertisements to reinforce the brand you are trying to establish.  Testimonials have a particularly strong impact on scientists because they are perceived as a kind of peer-review which commands respect in any scientific community. 

5.  Use simple but powerful advertisements to introduce specific products and services.  Don't get too flashy.  Scientists want to know how you can help them do their jobs better.     

4.  Make sure your customer service and technical support practices enhance the image you are trying to project.  All of your marketing efforts will be wasted if your customers become annoyed or frustrated in their dealings with you.  Word of incompetence travels quickly through the forensic science community and your company can't afford to have that happen. 

3.  Reach out to crime lab directors and supervisors.  They make the final purchasing decisions for their laboratories.  If you don't tap into this market segment, it can slow your progress over the long haul.  

2.  Measure the satisfaction of your customers regularly but unobtrusively.  Use brief surveys or set up a complaint system that gives you good feedback. Loss of market share can sneak up on you when you're dealing with the slow and often cumbersome pace of government laboratories.   

1.  Finally, keep reminding your employees that they are supporting an important public service that protects the safety of our citizens and the fairness of our criminal justice system.  Hopefully, this will generate an infectious enthusiasm that attracts potential customers to your business.  

Companies that follow these simple tips will certainly enjoy higher levels of success than their competitors. * * * * *

Please click here if you would like to respond to this commentary.  We welcome opposing viewpoints.
 

Subscribe to our free monthly report!
If you've received this report from a friend or colleague, you can subscribe now.  Information about our subscribers is kept private.

Email:

2008 SALARY SURVEY
for crime lab scientists and managers

Go to the survey
(just 10 minutes to complete)

Salary Survey is underway

Attention Crime Lab Directors - Please encourage your crime lab staff to subscribe to Crime Lab Report and complete our 2008 Annual Salary and Stability Survey.  Just ten minutes of their time will give you access to a wealth of information.  Go to www.crimelabreport.com to subscribe.


Letters to the Editors

The following opinions are personal observations and may not represent those of Crime Lab Report nor the organizations with whom these authors may be affiliated or employed.  They are listed in the order that they were received.

Crime Labs Under Police - Unresolved Issues

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Moses S. Schanfield, Ph.D.
Professor of Forensic Science
George Washington University

Nov 5, 2008

As a former crime laboratory director in both private and public labs, I found the editorial about crime labs under the police to be quite accurate. In my view, the multitude of problems in the media regarding crime laboratories whether it is Detroit, Wisconsin or Houston are multifold: funding restrictions leading to bad management decisions, inadequate management both in qualifications and personality, and inadequate supervision of quality assurance guidelines required under accreditation. Since every laboratory situation, whether public or private, is unique, there is no single solution to the problem. The good news is that the vast majority of forensic scientists working in laboratories are honest and serious scientists, producing reliable results that allow the criminal justice system to perform its job whether the roles of the police are biased or not. Physical evidence is a key to impartiality in plea agreements or criminal trials. In a review of cases where DNA evidence has exonerated convicted individuals, the majority of overturned cases were found to have been based on eye witness testimony and not physical evidence. Thus, yes there is a problem and its solution is difficult and murky and will require more money than is available in these times. But in spite of all these problems the system in general does work.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Kenton Wong, D-ABC
Senior Forensic Scientist
Forensic Analytical Services

Nov 5, 2008

Having worked for a law enforcement crime lab and now an independent crime lab (that serves both prosecutorial and defense agencies), I can honestly say that with working for law enforcement, there were always overzealous investigators or DA's that wanted you to hedge your opinion and be the "hero" in order to make/bolster their case. In the private lab setting, we inform clients that the examination results are objectively what they are, whether they like it or not and our results do not change based on who has hired us. Both defense attorneys and district attorneys thoroughly enjoy the fact that they can obtain much in court with an unbiased third party with no particular agenda - or "axe to grind". I for one especially see a serious conflict of interest where crime labs are under the jurisdiction of a DA's Office, and only slightly less so under a law enforcement structure. Thanks for taking responses.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Headlines

Chicago
Mystery Solved:  How bleach kills germs

"It seems that hypochlorous acid, the active ingredient in bleach, attacks proteins in bacteria, causing them to clump up much like an egg that has been boiled, a team at the University of Michigan reported in the journal Cell on Thursday. The discovery, which may better explain how humans fight off infections, came quite by accident."

 

Washington, D.C.
Supreme Court to rule on forensic lab reports
"The Supreme Court heard arguments on Monday in a case that could have broad implications for how prosecutors present evidence from crime laboratories at trial."

 

Detroit
Put scientists, not cops, in crime labs
"The good news is that Detroit may be no worse off than many other cities. The bad news is that the good news – if you can call it that – is really terrible. This is a crisis that is national in scope."

 

Wisconsin
Attorney challenges crime lab report

"A Brookfield attorney maintains that, contrary to the opinion of state Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen, all is not well at the state crime lab."

Washington, DC
As Rape Victims Wait, Money for Testing Goes Unused

"U.S. Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-N.Y.), who sponsored legislation that secured the funding for the Debbie Smith Act, is expressing her "strong concerns" about how the money is being spent."

California
Santa Clara Crime Lab Turns to RFID

"EPC Gen 2 tags will keep tabs on evidence as technicians perform DNA typing, fingerprint analysis, ballistics, toxicology and drug testing, and other procedures."

Arkansas
Lab lacked warrant for sweatshirt, lawyer says

"Attorneys for a man charged with capital murder claim a sweatshirt shouldn’t be allowed as evidence because police did not obtain a warrant to send it to the state Crime Laboratory."

Arizona
DPS hit up cities for crime lab fees

"The Arizona Department of Public Safety is charging cities for the use of its crime lab and cities say they are too strapped for cash and paying the fees would affect city services including local police departments."

Michigan
Opinion: Do not degrade Detroit's crime lab

"The recent problems in the Detroit Police Department Crime Laboratory have received national media attention. Despite the extensive coverage, the local news media have not sufficiently demanded clarification of the findings."

Washington, DC
Court weighs use of crime lab reports at trial

"The Supreme Court is being asked to rule whether crime lab reports used in drug and other cases may be introduced at trial without allowing defendants to cross-examine the forensic analysts who prepare them."

Arizona
Phoenix Crime Lab Understaffed, Overworked?

"A growing number of investigators have issues with the new Phoenix Crime Lab, according to a police union representative."


 

 


 

Please click here to contact CRIME LAB REPORT.  Our office hours are 5PM - 9PM Monday through Friday (CT).