Supplemental News & Announcements for July 2008
CRIME LAB REPORT
Media and public-policy analysis for the forensic science community

Copyright 2008 by Crime Lab Report.  All rights reserved.  This report contains opinions expressed by CRIME LAB REPORT, which is an independent organization.  These opinions may not necessarily represent those of our sponsors or other organizations affiliated with CRIME LAB REPORT and its editors.  While every effort is made to ensure accuracy and contextual honesty, all opinions should be corroborated with independent research before being construed as factual.  Crime Lab Report will quickly correct and/or retract any information demonstrated to be erroneous.  We welcome opposing viewpoints and will publish responses from our readers, which may be edited for economy and clarity.

www.crimelabreport.com

In the News

Florida
State Crime Lab Cuts Wait Times

Last year the FDLE began outsourcing some of its cases to private labs. The result was a considerable reduction in backlogged cases.

Texas
Chief's DNA Lab Trip Costs $14000

Houston Police Chief Harold Hurtt and several members of the department's crime lab recently traveled to London to learn more about analyzing DNA. But some are wondering if the trip was necessary because it will cost taxpayers thousands of dollars. 

Wisconsin
Van Hollen Unveils State Crime Lab Plans To Tackle DNA Backlog

State officials have unveiled an expanded State Crime Lab with the aim of reversing the DNA backlog.

South Carolina
DNA lab to take bite out of Beaufort County crime

The Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office is on pace to create its own DNA lab by the fall, becoming just the second local law enforcement agency in the state with the ability to analyze DNA.

Australia
The indelible fingerprint

Researchers have developed a method to ‘visualize fingerprints’ even after the print itself has been removed by measuring the corrosion caused by  the deposits from the fingerprints.

South Africa
Can we rely on the police?

Dozens of dedicated policemen and women were still leaving the force every month and the police's forensic laboratories were in a "complete mess".

Maryland
Man serves four months for crime he didn't commit

Detective claimed crime lab matched burglar's fingerprints when it didn't.

Texas
HPD DNA Lab Could Soon Be Back Open

The Houston Police Department's troubled DNA crime lab may soon be back in business after the department announced it has hired a new manager who now faces the critical job of restoring credibility to that office.

Colorado
Grant could bring crime lab to Northern Colorado

The seedling of a regional crime lab is likely headed toward Northern Colorado in the form of a $500,000 federal grant.

Nebraska
Lawyer: CSI chief will be cleared

A lawyer representing a suspended crime lab commander said he expects the investigator will be vindicated in connection with a Nebraska double murder investigation.

Virginia
Wanted: Lawyers to help locate felons from old cases

Virginia's Forensic Science Board is searching for lawyers to volunteer to help locate about 900 felons, some of whom may have been wrongly convicted.

New York
DAs warned of possible tainted cases

A state police forensic scientist's possible mishandling of evidence could affect criminal cases already disposed of in the north country.

Florida
Now you know how forensic science feels...
"There is no doubt that the media has a powerful influence on the public. When forensic science became a hit subject on shows like CSI
, the job market saw a significant increase in the forensic field. How much influence does a film like Indiana Jones have on new students entering the [archeology] field?"

Australia
Jurors' views skewed by the 'CSI effect'
"South Australia's police commissioner Mal Hyde, answering a question from Parliament's estimates committee, said television shows based on crime and forensic science could skew jurors' views on the use of such science in criminal cases, making it very difficult to convict a person if there was not a large amount of forensic evidence."

Washington, D.C.
Congress cuts police grants

"State and local law enforcement agencies likely will be seeking slices of a much smaller pie this year when it comes to one of their favorite, most flexible federal grant programs."


Texas
HPD DNA Lab Could Soon Be Back Open

"Confidence in the police DNA lab has been in short supply. Revelations of shoddy work, poor training and bad management caused it to be shut down not once but twice since 2002."

 

Interesting Topics

Is there really a "Boy Crisis"
Many crime laboratory managers have noticed the relatively small number of men applying for forensic science trainee positions.  Recent research has suggested that our current educational system has stacked the deck against boys.  But is this really true?

How Stuff Works:  Forensic Science Videos
The popular website "How Stuff Works" has recently posted a number of forensic science videos covering a variety of topics.

Bureau of Labor Statistics
If you've never taken a look at their outlook and profile of the forensic science job market, you may want to click this link to see how the Federal Bureau of Labor Statistics has it broken down.

 

Become a Subscriber

If this report was forwarded to you by a friend or colleague, you can receive your own free copy by subscribing at http://www.crimelabreport.com. You will receive two reports each month.  All we need is your name and email address.  We will not share your information with any third parties.
 

Letters to the Editors

The following were two thought-provoking letters in response to last month's editorial on licensing in forensic science:

Dear Crime Lab Report: 
The California Association of Criminalists (CAC), when developing its own certification program in the 1980’s actually contacted the State of California’s Department of Consumer Affairs, the folks who do licensing in California  We were essentially told by the State that criminalistics was too small a group to be economically viable as a field to be licensed.  Their interest wasn’t in a NEED for licensing, just whether it could make money.  

Laboratory accreditation is driven, at least in part, by the need for a lab to be accredited before receiving grant funds.  There is no concomitant drive, however, for certification.  Few criminalists, if certified, get any incentive for that certification - and no credit is given toward their lab’s accreditation, which would certainly encourage laboratory management to have certified criminalists in their laboratories. 

I happen to be a peace officer.  Like most peace officers, I get a financial incentive for having two POST certificates, or in my case, approximately an 8% pay increase.  I've worked much harder to get and keep my two certifications as a Fellow of the American Board of Criminalistics, than my POST certificates.  I must pay ABC’s annual fees personally and receive little recognition and no financial reward from my employer for that ABC certification. 

Incentives for certification are purely personal now.  One way for it to become widespread would be to require the linkage of certification to accreditation.  The other would be for lab managers to attach fiscal incentives to certification.

Hiram K. Evans, M.Sc., F-AAFS, F-ABC
Past President, California Association of Criminalists
San Bernardino Co. Sheriff-Coroner's Department
Scientific Investigations Division

 

Dear Crime Lab Report:
I disagree with the following comment in your editorial on licensing in forensic science:

"Within the profession, the single-most powerful credential that a practitioner can present to a jury is that he or she works in an accredited laboratory.  It is even more powerful than certification."  

I have worked in forensics for about 30 years and testified 150 times.   I've been asked only once if my lab was accredited; however, I've been asked about my personal certification in the majority of cases in which I have testified.  My discussions with fellow forensic experts in virtually all disciplines have confirmed this same experience.

I certainly agree that there is value in working in an accredited laboratory, and that it helps when an expert asks a court to accept them as an expert.   But personal credentials and one's certification, are simply more critical.  That some courts now look at laboratory accreditation more closely is a result of the increased adverse publicity concerning crime labs in recent years. 

Joseph Parker
Forensic Document Examiner
Peachtree City, Georgia


Upcoming Meetings and Conferences

Please send us an email if you'd like us to announce an upcoming event.  We will post meeting announcements for major events only.

(IAFS)      International Association of Forensic Sciences
July 21-26, 2008   New Orleans, Louisiana

(IAI)         International Association for Identification
August 17-23, 2008    Louisville, Kentucky

(NAME)    National Association of Medial Examiners
September 5-10, 2008     Louisville, KY

(ASCLD)  American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors
September 14-18, 2008   Salt Lake City, Utah

(SAFS)     Southern Association of Forensic Scientists
September 21-26, 2008    Shreveport, Louisiana

(SWAFS)  Southwestern Association of Forensic Scientists
September 22-26, 2008   Little Rock, Arkansas

(MAFS)    Midwestern Association of Forensic Scientists
September 28 - October 3, 2008     Des Moines, Iowa

(NAFS)     Northwest Association of Forensic Scientists
November 3-7, 2008   Boise, Idaho

(AAFS)    American Academy of Forensic Sciences
February 16-21, 2009     Denver, CO

(MAAFS)  Mid Atlantic Association of Forensic Scientists
May 4-8, 2009    Hunt Valley, MD

(AFTE)     Association of Firearm & Toolmark Examiners
May 31 - June 5, 2009   Miami Beach, FL   

(Special Joint Meeting)   MAAFS, MAFS, SAFS, SWAFS
October 18-23, 2009    Orlando, FL
 

 


 

Please click here to contact CRIME LAB REPORT.  Our office hours are 5PM - 9PM Monday through Friday (CT).